Bookmark Mutual Insurance Site!


For more than 40 years, Mutual Insurance Agency has provided outstanding service and high-quality, cost-effective insurance products to businesses, individuals and non-profit organizations.  Founded in 1962, Mutual Insurance has been continually researching plan offerings and partnering with a wide range of carriers. Our goal has been to develop the coverage’s’ and pricing that best meet each valued customer’s needs.

Churches, Schools and Non-profits

Mutual has the expertise and knowledge in helping churches and other faith-based organizations implement risk management policies and procedures which safeguard their people, facilities and ministries. Since 1976, Mutual has partnered with more than 2,000 organizations setting up customized risk assessment programs. Our value added services offer an array of tools that can help you identify and determine the best way to deal with potential concerns. Our loss control inspections and personnel screening provide for accurate property safety and security, youth protection, transportation safety, workers compensation and emergency response preparation.

Risk Management Approach

Every industry and every company has its own special insurance coverage needs. No matter what your needs, Mutual Insurance assumes the role of your risk management partner and works with you to establish the programs to satisfy them. In addition, Mutual Insurance prides itself on the value added services which assess your risks and provide support to minimize your exposure. In the event you have to make a claim, we provide advanced claim service to assist you in the process.

We have developed successful master programs for the Church of the Nazarene, Southwest Educational Region (CA, AZ, NV) and the Mennonite Church, Pacific Southwest Conference (CA, AZ). We are fully licensed to provide insurance services in California, Arizona and Nevada.

Agency Principals:

Howard Wooton, Principal
Paul Wooton, Principal
Douglas Wooton, Senior Account Executive
Lisa Anderson, Claims Manager